Your First Audit Part 3 of 4
Your bank will confirm your cash. Your customers will confirm what they owe. Your lender will confirm the loan balance.
Nobody will write back to confirm that your slow-moving stock is still worth what you say it is. No third party will verify that the goodwill from an acquisition three years ago has not gone backwards. There is no register you can search to prove a doubtful debt provision is enough.
This is where a first audit slows down, and where first-time clients are most surprised. Existence and ownership can be evidenced from outside the business. Valuation cannot.
An estimate is audited on its method, not just its answer
The instinct is to defend the number. Auditors are not really arguing about the number.
Auditing accounting estimates is its own standard, ASA 540, and the work runs to how the estimate was built as well as to the figure it produced. An auditor who can follow your method, your assumptions and the data behind them can test whether the answer is reasonable, and a documented method is what makes a range of answers defensible. An auditor who cannot see how you got there has nothing to test, including when the number turns out to be right. “How did you arrive at that?” is a request for the working, not a challenge to your judgement.
The four that take the time
Impairment, under AASB 136. Goodwill, intangibles, plant. Impairment means writing an asset down when the books carry it above what it can actually earn or fetch, so the question is whether the value on your balance sheet still holds. The answer usually rests on a cash-flow forecast prepared inside the business, by the people closest to the asset, which is why the assumptions inside it get as much attention as the total.
Expected credit losses on receivables. Your bad-debt provision is no longer a question of which invoices have already gone bad; it is a forward-looking estimate of what you expect to lose. For ordinary trade debtors that usually means an ageing-based loss rate rather than tracking each customer’s credit standing.
Stock obsolescence. Slow-moving and superseded inventory is a valuation judgement with a paper trail sitting right there in your system: ageing, movement history, sell-through. Producing that trail is what turns the conversation from an argument into a review.
Going concern, under ASA 570. The question is whether the business can be expected to keep operating for the foreseeable future. In practice that means cash-flow forecasts and facility letters. Going concern work is a standing part of a statutory audit, not a signal of concern about your business, and it lands better when the documents exist before they are requested.
Where technology moves the line, and where it does not
Auditors have always worked from a selection rather than every transaction. Where a complete, reliable data set is available, testing can run across the whole population instead, which changes the shape of an audit: questions concentrate on genuine outliers rather than on whatever a sample happened to catch.
What that needs from you is one thing done well, a clean and complete data extract at the start. What it does not do is settle a judgement. Analysis can surface that a group of customers has drifted past 120 days for the first time. Whether that is a collections problem or a credit-loss problem is still a decision a person makes, defends and documents.
That is the honest limit of an augmented audit. It removes the manual search. It does not remove the judgement.
The habit that saves you at fieldwork
Estimates are difficult to reconstruct months later. The memory of why a discount rate was 11.5% fades faster than anyone expects, and rebuilding the reasoning under deadline pressure produces a worse answer than the one you originally had.
How much documentation is worth the effort is a call for management, not the auditor, so what follows is guidance rather than a requirement. A short file note made at the time, covering method, assumptions, source data, who approved it and the date, turns a contested estimate into a supported one. It takes minutes while you are making the estimate and saves considerable rework when the audit asks for it.
Next in the series: the letter that arrives after all of this is finished, and why it is not the criticism it looks like.
- 1Canva Paid $792,000 for Lodging Late. Are You Even in Scope?
- 2Why Your Auditor Writes to Your Bank Instead of Reading Your Bank Statement
- 3The Numbers Nobody Can ConfirmYou are here
- 4Findings Aren’t Failures: What to Do With the Management LetterComing next